Chapter 2 of 23

The method: claim, source, leap

Illustration: magnifying glass
In plain language
The speaker often starts with something true, like a real Bible verse or a real news story, and then jumps to a big conclusion that doesn't follow from it. This slide teaches a four-step check: Is the source real? What does it actually say? Does his conclusion follow? Does it really apply to all Jews?
The claim
Expect the opponent to present a real quotation or event, attach a sweeping interpretation, then treat the interpretation as proven.
Sources cited
The supplied transcript repeatedly moves from one person or event to an entire people, and from prophetic language to modern political conclusions.
Key facts
Separate four things: whether the source is authentic, what it says in context, whether the interpretation follows, and whether the conclusion is generalizable.

Chapter 2 chat

Talk about this chapter. For everything else, use the main chat.

  • No messages yet.
Sign in to join the chat

We email you a one-time sign-in link. No password needed.